in a long run, my vote goes to planet pop corn as its cheaper and not as sweet as garrett. no doubt garett caramel with macadamia its nice but it gets too sweet after awhile. however if just caramel alone without the nuts, it actually taste much better. as in not too sweet. My fav planet pop corn will have to be Cheese and Sea weed. For garrett,will be caramel. Their cheese and corn is too salty for me.